Despite the Odds, Sea Shepherd Wins Another Battle in Whale Wars

The crew of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society is back on Animal Planet for a new season of Whale Wars. The crew qualifies as the bravest of activists as they literally risk their lives on a daily basis to fight the Japanese whaling industry.

Out in the open water, there is no one to intervene between the whalers and the activists. The crew members of Sea Shepherd are the little guys, seemingly the underdog, compared to their foes, the well-funded Japanese whaling industry. But this match-up has not just been created for television drama - the clash has been ongoing for over 30 years with Captain Paul Watson at the helm. Sea Shepherd started this particular campaign against the Japanese whalers in the Southern Ocean in the Antarctic in 2002. In this extreme environment, the Sea Shepherd crew face ice that ripped a hole in one vessel in a previous season and “rogue waves” which in this season, severed a pontoon of the Brigitte Bardot, a vessel named after the actress and animal activist who accompanied the Sea Shepherd on a voyage in 1977.

The Sea Shepherd crew fights the whalers in order to help uphold the world-wide moratorium on commercial whale hunting. However, the Japanese state that their self-proclaimed “scientific whaling” is exempt from the ban. They produce data on whale size, DNA and contents of their digestive tracks but killing 500 whales of the same species in the same location to compile this data seems outrageous, especially when other countries like Australia conduct non-lethal research. The Japanese use their data to argue that since whales eat fish, they must be killed to reduce populations and keep the fishery business alive. This argument ignores the fact that the fishing industry has made itself non-sustainable thanks to huge kills of fish using drift nets that extend for miles (which also trap species such as dolphins). The whale products are sold commercially in Japanese markets.

Sea Shepherd’s goal is to cause enough interference so that the whalers cannot carry out whaling activities. The Japanese harpoon boats usually travel next to the main factory ship, the Nisshin Maru, which hauls in and cuts up whales that the harpoon ships kill. Sea Shepherd’s primary tactic is to follow the Nisshin Maru so it must try to get away instead of drop anchor and haul in the bodies. Further, the harpoon ships often divert from killing in order to aid the mother ship. In 2010, a harpoon ship rammed and sunk the Ady Gil, a boat donated to Sea Shepherd by the Hollywood entrepreneur with the same name. The collision broke three ribs of Animal Planet cameraman, Simeon Houtman.

The whalers also turn the tables by following the Sea Shepherd crew. By monitoring the location of Sea Shepherd vessels, the whalers know where not to go to pursue their hunt. The chase becomes a game of cat-and-mouse as Sea Shepherd crew must try to outwit the vessels that pursue them.

Sea Shepherd uses methods to slow and frustrate the Nisshin Maru’s crew, but do not harm any individual. For example, Sea Shepherd tries to clear the Nisshin Maru’s decks by tossing bottles of non-toxic, biodegradable but stinky butyric acid on board, sending the crew running to avoid the smell. If the crew is not on the deck, they can’t receive and cut up the whales, plus the whale meat becomes tainted. Sea Shepherd may also maneuver to strategically toss a rope in front of the Nisshin Maru or a harpoon boat, entangling the ship’s propeller so the whalers must stop and detangle it. To prevent the harpooners from shooting the whales, Sea Shepherd has sometimes invoked photonic disrupters - lasers designed not to cause damage, but to blind temporarily and disorient, like flashbulbs.

In the last year, the Japanese whaling industry received $30 million of misdirected tsunami relief funds to bolster their efforts and deflect the Sea Shepherd. This is on top of the annual $6 million subsidy from the Japanese government. With this money, the whaling industry invests in high-tech defenses, including water cannons and LRADs (high decibel long range acoustical devices) designed to incapacitate recipients. They have aimed the LRAD at Sea Shepherd’s crew, including their helicopter pilot in flight. This is a true David and Goliath match-up since Sea Shepherd relies solely on donations. But David is winning - in the last several whaling seasons, the Japanese have slaughtered much fewer minke and fin whales than their planned quota, causing profit losses of tens of millions of dollars.

Whale Wars is just one campaign of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society. They also address seal hunting in Canada and Namibia, dolphin hunting in Japan, pilot whale hunting in the Faroe Islands and the overfishing of blue fin tuna. Of course, like most television shows, the current season was previously recorded and ended in March (as temperatures decline in the Southern Hemisphere). At this very moment, Captain Paul Watson is detained in Germany for possible extradition to Costa Rica. The charge stems back to 2002, when the Sea Shepherd documented illegal shark-finning by a Costa Rican vessel in Guatemalan waters. At the time, Guatemala allowed the Sea Shepherd to intervene and stop the shark-finning. This Costa Rican vessel had been previously convicted of poaching in the Galapagos Island. The Costa Rican crew claimed that their lives were threatened by Sea Shepherd and as a result, the Costa Rican government issued a demand of extradition for Captain Watson. This demand has been dismissed by Interpol for being politically motivated but 10 years later, Germany has upheld it.

There is now a worldwide campaign, including celebrity support, to release Captain Watson so he can continue his brave work to save whales and other marine species. Over the years, Sea Shepherd has gained support from celebrities such as Bob Barker, Pierce Brosnan, Martin Sheen, Sean Penn, John Paul DeJoria (of Paul Mitchell), Pamela Anderson, Flea, the Red Hot Chili Peppers, the late Steve Irwin, and even the Dali Lama.

While detained in Germany, Watson has recently met with Sam Simon, co-creator of The Simpsons, who will be donating a new ship to the Sea Shepherd’s fleet. The ship, named after Simon, will be seen on the next season of Whale Wars.

Written by Valerie Chalcraft


Submitted by Jena OC (not verified) on
Are these guys on their own or do they get some government support? If on their own then this is really risky. How about the Japanese whalers. Are they just hunting whales for the sake of research? Where is the meat of these whales sold: in which markets?

Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on
Sea Shepherd gets no financial support from any government but they are international now and different countries allow them to fly their flags, a form of support. The Japanese just use the research excuse as a cover to continue commercial whaling. From what I understand, it appears openly in many Japanese markets

Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on
Whale meat even for sale on Yahoo Japan! Unfortunately, I can't post the link here but the Natural Resources Defense Council has a petition to Ross Levinsohn, Interim CEO, Yahoo! Inc. asking him to drop whale meat from Yahoo Japan. You might be able to find the petition with an internet search.

Submitted by Jenny Jack (not verified) on
It's unfortunate that whale meat can be purchased in such companies like Yahoo! Japan. I think the company needs to somehow curb this to bring it's contribution to saving these animals.

Submitted by PAS (not verified) on
They could never get the support of any government because everything they do is illegal. They endanger the lives of themselves and everyone they come within 100 miles of with their dangerous ship maneuvering and patented Capn Paul incompetence.

Submitted by Poseiden (not verified) on
I am going to guess that your last meal was whale meat?? There is no "scientific" analisys of the whales....i would live to see the "data" they have gathered....and report acurately what they have done with the whale meat after their "analisys".

Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on
Actually they have the support of the Australian government....and what the Japanese do is illegal. They are commercially whaling with "scientific research" as a flimsy cover.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
Research is just a loophole they use as an excuse to kill whale - to make it seem legitimate. The whale meat is found in markets all over Japan.

Submitted by Dante (not verified) on
Paul Watson is one of the few who scores in nature preservation in a measurable way. The battle is long and hard with no end, which can only be fought by courage and determination. In fact guilt is probably the real motive. We now that by our presence today on this planet as a human being, we contribute to the decline of the planet and its nature, wildlife included. Some people sacrifice everything to compensate this during their life, like Paul Watson. We should all realize our humble place on this planet and the shamefull role we play in nature.

Submitted by Trish (not verified) on
I agree completly with Dante, Paul Watson and his fellow Sea Shepards are true Hero's!! I just started watching Whale Wars and I am disgusted with the Japanese government with the money sent to them to recover from the Tsunami to "Beef" up these ships of death! Whales are the oldest species on this Earth and they should be protected at any and all cost!! I am so glad the Shepards are getting more ships to take these Killers on and save these defenseless animals. There has to be a Global agreement that all should follow in any open waters no matter where that it is illegal to harm these magestic animals!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
What is wrong with you people. How can you come to the conclusion that that incompetent fat boy who is a terrible leader, not even a licensed captain, and does everything for his own personal fame a hero? I dont advocate the killing of whales but at the same time I don't advocate joining forces with that mouth breathing idiot. I could go on and on about his lies, manipulation, and ridiculous/questionable ideas but that would be to much. I don't know if it is because people want to believe in something so much they look past it all, or whether people have been lead to believe that so much is wrong with the world that stuff like this is needed. Either way it's ridiculous and people should open their eyes. When are we going to start worrying about humans again?

Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on
Paul Watson has been doing this for decades before the TV show is that fame-seeking? He is a very personable, down-to-earth person who remains level-headed while taking on some unimaginable pressure. I bet you can't even name one "lie". If we worry only about short-sighted human goals (ex. make as much money as possible), then the world in which humans live will be gone.

Submitted by Dante (not verified) on
Whales and other animals have the same right to live on this planet as humans, if not more. Don't forget that you and your fellow 'humans' are at the origin of the destruction of nature of this planet. You don't come with any arguments, just stupid emotional downtalk.

Submitted by Alexander (not verified) on
+1 to Dante. The thinking ape is a devious, greedy and dangerous animal, exploiting anything and everything in his path. Our species has raped and pillaged everything they have come in contact with. Conservation is really damage control. Regardless of Watson's tactics and motivations, one should only judge the man from the results of his campaigns. The simple fact of the matter is that for the last few years the Sea Shepherd harassment of the Japanese whaling fleet has saved whales. For the last two seasons they have actually managed to force the Japanese to quit their season early, thus saving many whales. This would NEVER have happened if they were to just follow the ships talking pictures like Greenpeace does. You cannot stop those guys with talk, profit is their game and the only way to stop them is to be prepared to harash them as much as possible; and Watson and his people are some of the very FEW who have balls to do something about it and actually make the difference. This is a self-explanatory, absolute, non-debatable fact that only a fool with impaired rasoning could ever reject or deny.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
I absolutely 100% DO NOT agree with whaling. I think killing such a majestic animal is almost as much a crime as killing a human. That said, Paul Watson is an idiot. He is incompetent and its by pure luck or the grace of God (whatever you beleive in) that he hasn't gotten someone killed already. He runs the ships like a tyrant (off-camera, of course) -- I know some that have served in his crew. He takes millions from do-gooder celebrities and blows it on frivolities like fancy camo paint jobs for the ships and then gives assinine orders like sending the Bardot into 30-foot seas only to do another quater-million in damage. He gets them to pledge their lives during these little pre-show interviews, but then you see how they crap their pants when something that gets them close to death happens. He preys on young idealistic treehuggers that have no idea what they're getting into. Notice the repeat faces are few from season to season... only his inner hardcore circle keeps coming back.... for the "real" crew its one season and gone! Whaling has to stop -- but the ends DO NOT justify the means. Before this is all over, people will die. I'm sorry, but I would not trade human lives to save some whales.

Submitted by Dante (not verified) on
You are probably right about many things you say about Paul Watson. I agree that I was very surprised that a fibreglass(?) trimaran was operating into the Southern Oceans and was not surprised to read about the damage. I have been on the Steve Irwin and would not call 'ship shape' what I saw. I am a former sailing yacht captain and have crossed the oceans. Then again, he has reults whre others don't, luck or not. Because his operations are dangerous, and I believe reckless, they are material for TV series and get a wide public support.People world wide are now more aware of the whale hunting and the shark finning. They speak up, give support and goverments cannot ignore this anymore. Also these series bring in a lot of money, which of course gets partly wasted, but they can buy equipment and make repairs when needed. Saving a whale is like saving a human live...

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
another moron is heard from. maybe we should keep taking pictures and shaking our fingers at japanese and hope they stop. At least they are willing to step up to the plate and risk their lives for a cause that means something. You just sit on your butt and pass judgement on those that are actually making a difference. Unbelievable. Crawl back into your hole and keep your dumb remarks to yourself.

Submitted by DIY (not verified) on
I can sit back and second-guess Paul Watson just as well as anyone else. He's not 007 or whatever movie hero you might want him to be. So go out and do a better job. I'm serious. Get a fleet of ships, wrangle up millions in donations and do a better job. Nobody is stopping you.