Dave Hester's lawsuit reveals his salary and more

Paula Duffy's picture

The Storage Wars celeb Dave "Yuuup" Hester filed a civil suit against Storage Wars producers and A&E. What's his beef against them?

Hester's litigation papers not only set out his complaints and demands to be protected from lawsuits that could arise from what he called fraudulent behavior, his salary and other compensation perks are made public. Meanwhile, there are new shows airing and Hester is still on-air. Read about his clash with Jeff Jarred, here.

The new episodes have been off the air for a couple of weeks through the holidays and replaced with another spinoff. Storage Wars New York has arrived and it's a breath of fresh air. Read more about that, here.

Allegations against the defendants as listed in the filed papers include:

1) "A&E regularly plants valuable items or memorabilia" "...in one episode a pile of old newspapers announcing the death of Elvis Presley was discovered. In another episode a BMW mini car was found buried under a pile trash."

When Hester went to the producers to say he thought what they were doing might be illegal he was fired.

2) "...nearly every aspect of the Series is faked, even down to the plastic surgery that one of the female cast members underwent in order to create more 'sex appeal'"

The cost of the surgery was picked up for her. In the land of plastic surgery mills, So. Cal, does anyone find that a problem? Hester does.

3) "Original Productions (producers of the show) manipulate the outcome of auctions by paying for storage units on behalf of the weaker cast members who lack both the skill and financial wherewithal to place winning bids."

Who's weak? Perhaps Brandi and Jarrod before they got their feet wet? Darrell's got money and we know that Barry does.

4) "...many viewers have questioned whether the valuable items are planted in the units for dramatic effect. In response AETN (A&E) issued the following press release. 'There is no staging involved. The items uncovered in the storage units are the actual items featured on the show.' That was a lie."

5) "Hester is informed and believes that a company called Off The Wall Antiques provides defendants access to an entire warehouse full of marquee items, and in exchange the owners of that establishment are regularly featured on the Series."

Does the name Off The Wall Antiques sound familiar? It should. The Storage Wars gang, mostly Barry Weiss who is chums with the owner, shows up there to have Dennis Boses appraise something for him.

6) "Although the Series shows cast members who have won storage units breaking away from the rest of the cast to inspect the contents of the unit during the auction, this never occurs."

7) During early seasons of the show, "...Defendants requested that Hester provide valuable items that would be planted...in the storage lockers acquired by Hester." "....he soon realized that he did not want to participate in this fraudulent conduct. Hester complained....and in response Defendants no longer requested..."

The complaint then details his attempts to tell the defendants that he didn't want to be part of them planting items in others' storage lockers, despite them ceasing to do it with his.

In September 2012 at a series of meetings with A&E top brass and senior execs of the production company, the other cast members joined Hester and agreed they were queasy about it continuing to go on.

This occurred after his contract option was picked up for this latest season. Hester's salary and other compensation? $25,000 per episode for a guarantee of 26, plus a monthly stipend of $2,500 AND an expense account of $124,500 plus a $25,000 signing bonus.

The extent of planting items in lockers was revealed to the top execs. As you would expect, at their level they didn't know the extent to which it continued. Hester's attorney wrote to them and asked that if they continued the practice, Hester wanted protection from any lawsuits or investigations into their practices.

He was fired after that. Meanwhile there are two new episodes set to air tonight on A&E. How does this affect your view of the show?

There's more detail where that came from and here's the link to the documents.

Want to read a bit about Hester's Hollywood attorney? Click here. Image: A&E/Storage Wars poster


Submitted by htoler (not verified) on
I told my son that I thought items were being planted. Seems strange that expensive items are found in the back. I ,also, have bought storage lockers with nothing like they are finding. Why do shows have to be "rigged"

Submitted by fattz (not verified) on
YO ...the super bowl.....the world series ...NBA finals DUH it is all fixed what makes you think this crappy show isn't ?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
you're an idiot if you truely believe that all professional sports are rigged. the only evidence that you need to contradict your imaginative theory is the ego amoungst professional atheletes. these guys can't even have an after game interview without some sort interuption by another camera hungry immature teammate. you sir, are an average, ignorant american that probably has trouble with roundabouts.

Submitted by fattz (not verified) on
YO ...the super bowl.....the world series ...NBA finals DUH it is all fixed what makes you think this crappy show isn't ?

Submitted by beth marshall (not verified) on
Go gettum Dave! This show is a blatant to boost sales for American Auctioneers, Inc., and the Storage Locker Assn, and ad revenue for A&E. If they are salting the lockers before they are sold, that is a serious violation of CA state law...which could cause Dan Dotson to lose his auctioneer license in CA. If they are using totally fake "abandoned lockers", or salting after the lockers are purchased, they are not violating state storage locker laws, but what they are doing is highly unethical and borderline illegal, as there is no disclaimer during the show stating that what you are watching is staged. Even Pro wrestling has had to call their shows "entertainment" to stay legal. Dan Dotson is swearing that everything is legit, cause if he doesn't he'll lose everything. He's positioning himself to be able to say "I didn't know", if all the fakery comes out in court. A&E is probably having meetings with their lawyers to get opinions on where they stand...but if they have any brains, they are taking this seriously. All they need is for someone to sue them for attempted price manipulation in the marketplace..that's a federal offense that the feds take seriously.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
It says in the complaint they were salted after being bought.They had to use A&E locks after winning the bid.

Submitted by Matt (not verified) on
I would be mad if I lost a million dollar job too. What a cry baby! Did anyone really think they " found" all of this stuff. In my opinion Dave is a moron who was in on it the whole time and is mad about loosing his job.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
Dave Hester is a douchebag who uses intimidation to try and scare people. He treats people like crap and has the manners and morals of a gorilla. no one liked him and he was asked to leave the show...simple as that. now he tries to sue A & E and stomps his feet like a little baby throwing a temper tantrum. good riddance to bad rubbish. Karma is going to kick his ass one day.

Submitted by Storage Wars Watcher (not verified) on
The show is for entertainment. Who cares if it is staged? If I wanted something real this wouldn't be the show too watch.


Add new comment