Meet the Hutterites: Was bringing King Colony to the masses a mistake?

Mechele R. Dillard's picture

Meet the Hutterites is supposed to be a glimpse into the world of the Hutterites, but not everyone seems to appreciate the attempt to make the views of this religion more public.

Meet the Hutterites came to the National Geographic Channel promising an insider’s view to the colony’s way of life, which seemed like an interesting chance for viewers to learn more about the religion and “meet” some of the members of the faith. But, not everyone is seeing things eye-to-eye regarding the “reality” presented in the early episodes.

Some Huliq readers, claiming to be Hutterites themselves, commented on why King Colony may have agreed to do the show:

  • Anonymous: “I am a Hutterite living on a colony in Manitoba...The reason they are doing this? It could be more or less because they want to get the message and perspective out of who and what Hutterites really are. No; don’t color us all with the same brush, but personally, for me, I enjoy showing and telling the outside world who and what I am. There is nothing freakish about our trends or rituals; everything we have and do is sensible, even if outsiders would not necessarily agree with it. I sometimes feel like outsiders get the wrong impression about us, maybe because of a bad influence one or more of my fellow members might have somewhere...But I still like to do my part in showing who we really are.”
  • Anonymous: “Are they doing it for the sake of becoming Hollywood Television stars? Yes, I have an issue with that; exploiting my heritage for fame and fortune, even by a member of my own kind, would in my opinion by doing something for the wrong reason. Having said that; it has been done before. There are a few documentary productions that have been made where outsiders are invited to come into the community for a week or two. As far as I'm concerned, I think it answers a few questions, and clears a few opinions outsiders have about us.”

However, following the airing of another episode, just a few days later, one of the anonymous commenters posted the following:

“I take back my words: I was on the impression that these folks might be doing it for a better reason than they obviously are...The show is an embarrassment to Hutterites and the Hutterite lifestyle. Shame on King Colony and National Geographics. Total disgrace.”

And, other readers, also calling themselves Hutterites, were angered by the show, as well:

  • Herb: “These people are a disaster!!! I call them HINO's, Hutterites In Name Only!! Shame, shame, double shame!!! Making a mockery of themselves and the lives they are supposed to be living!! They have no class, no character, pitiful!!! As for Natgeotv, they are classless, characterless clowns who are purposefully and knowingly perpetrating a mockery and a lie to further there sick and perverse agenda. They did limited research on their subject because they are not interested in the truth. As a true Hutterite it angers me!! God have mercy on them.”
  • Anonymous: I am a Hutterite living on a colony in Manitoba...What a disgrace, a shameful disgrace. This show is entertainment, but that is it. These folks have absolutely no resemblance to Hutterites other than having a similar dress-code. Morals, ethics, lifestyle...theyre gone. Just gone. No wonder they're not accepted by one of the 3 Hutterian Churches. These aren't Hutterites; simply entertainment. When is the next show coming out? I can't wait.”

Does King Colony Regret Meet the Hutterites?

Following some of the not-so-glowing comments, this anonymous message appeared:

“This community temporarily lost sight of who they are and allowed themselves to be swayed by a secular organization who were obviously on their own agenda, with seemingly no thought that an entire people are hurt by this. King Ranch leadership now deeply regrets their actions, and know that the money they got was not worth what they're experiencing now. I'm praying some good will come of this, but I can't imagine what it might be.”

Although this anonymous commenter spoke with authority about King Colony, it is not confirmed that, indeed, this individual was speaking for the colony or those involved with the show. However, it does raise the question, did the Hutterites of King Colony understand what they were opening themselves—and other Hutterites—up to when they signed on to do this National Geographic reality television show?

One reader may have summed up the situation perfectly:

“Wrong title, it should be ‘Exploit the Hutterites.’”

Will viewers agree? And will they keep coming back to Meet the Hutterites?

Stay tuned.

UPDATE: Ex-Hutterite gives personal testimony about colony life

Meet the Hutterites airs on Tuesdays on the National Geographic Channel at 10 p.m E/P.

Image: Wikimedia Commons

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
My daughter and I have thoroughly enjoyed watching and learning about the Hutterite life. We have been amazed by complexities of balancing tradition and modern progress. Some embrace the technology and modern conveniences while other seem to fear it. Our saddest observation was having to witness the concession of education versus the Hutterite woman training. It's a real shame that a compromise couldn't be found, training during the summer months, or after completing a their high school education. We do wish more about the life style had been shown, courting rituals, or even more references to the religious beliefs. We came to watch to learn, as we have in the past lived in communities with Amish and Mennonite. We have especially enjoyed Claudia's spirit. She's bright, strong willed and a beautiful young lady.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
My daughter and I have thoroughly enjoyed watching and learning about the Hutterite life. We have been amazed by complexities of balancing tradition and modern progress. Some embrace the technology and modern conveniences while other seem to fear it. Our saddest observation was having to witness the concession of education versus the Hutterite woman training. It's a real shame that a compromise couldn't be found, training during the summer months, or after completing a their high school education. We do wish more about the life style had been shown, courting rituals, or even more references to the religious beliefs. We came to watch to learn, as we have in the past lived in communities with Amish and Mennonite. We have especially enjoyed Claudia's spirit. She's bright, strong willed and a beautiful young lady.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
My daughter and I have thoroughly enjoyed watching and learning about the Hutterite life. We have been amazed by complexities of balancing tradition and modern progress. Some embrace the technology and modern conveniences while other seem to fear it. Our saddest observation was having to witness the concession of education versus the Hutterite woman training. It's a real shame that a compromise couldn't be found, training during the summer months, or after completing a their high school education. We do wish more about the life style had been shown, courting rituals, or even more references to the religious beliefs. We came to watch to learn, as we have in the past lived in communities with Amish and Mennonite. We have especially enjoyed Claudia's spirit. She's bright, strong willed and a beautiful young lady.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
Please stop telling these people they are a disgrace!! stop telling these people how to live and what to say and do!! you should be a shamed of your selfves and live and let live.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
I LOVE this show... It gives us a glimpse into the lifes of a tradition that has been going on for over a hundred and fifty years... They show us the way that other cultures live and how that hard work and that family can function in todays society... Great show... Please bring more of the Hutterites....

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
I have enjoyed watching this show. Although it seems funng at times. because these people are dfferent, have different beliefs and agendas. However, I think the one thing we all should take from them is that they are a community. I find it imressing that if one needs help, one can make a phone call and some one will be willing to help. Where in the "English" world can one count on some one helping out. The "English world is so abut "ME" and "MINE" that no none else matters.Instead of poking fun at these people we should be trying to see what we can learn from them. Whether you agree with their lifestyle, beliefs,styles I think we all can learn something from them. And by no means am I saying that we should emulate these people, but learn something.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on
I really love this show, and I hope that this tv show will never end...that it will always continue..every season, I would miss it

Submitted by christine from ... (not verified) on
Go for second season,i would like to see that as well.:)

Submitted by christine from ... (not verified) on
Thank you,it's nice to be back:),i guess that's what this bulletin is all about,debating judgements of one another.i love watching the hutterites,as a matter of fact I recently came upon a website of two hutterite colonies in montana,the one was king colony,i retreived mrs. ritas e-mail add,as it was offered,and I will be purchasing a "quillow" and hopefully morethings,i fully intend to support the hutterite colony(king colony)

Pages

Add new comment