Skip to main content

Iran Sets Conditions For British Sailors' Release

Tehran is demanding London acknowledge it violated Iran's territorial waters before the case of 15 detained British sailors and marines can be resolved.

Iranian Foreign Minister Manuchehr Mottaki made the demand on March 28. It came shortly after Iranian television broadcast footage of some of the detained Britons.

The footage included Faye Turney, the only woman crew member, who said the sailors and marines had "trespassed" into Iranian waters.

"Obviously we trespassed into their waters. They were very friendly, very hospitable, very thoughtful, nice people," Turney said.

"They explained to us why we'd been arrested. There was no aggression, no hurt, no harm. They were very, very compassionate," she added.

Britain promptly rejected the new Iranian condition, meaning the standoff is likely to continue for some time.

The Iranian TV broadcast was shown on one of the country's Arabic-language stations, with the clear intent of getting maximum regional coverage.

British Defense Minister Des Browne condemned the move.

"I've seen the footage, obviously, of Faye Turney and her comrades, and I don't really intend to dwell on the nature of that footage or, indeed, the way in which it was put into the public domain other than to say it is completely unacceptable to parade our people in this way," Browne said.

British officials mounted an extensive media campaign on March 28, using charts and coordinates to prove that the vessel in question, the HMS Cornwall, had not strayed into Iranian waters.

By demanding an admission of wrongdoing from London, Tehran may be indicating that it sees the conflict as a matter of national pride and honor, rather than a technical matter.

The seizure of the British sailors and marines came as Iran faced defeat in the UN Security Council over its nuclear ambitions and at the same time as the United States Navy conducted its largest exercise in Persian Gulf waters since 2003.

Those maneuvers, involving two U.S. aircraft carriers sailing close to Iran's shores, but in international waters, are due to end today.

In another development, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon held talks with Iran's foreign minister in the Saudi capital Riyadh today, on the sidelines of a Mideast peace conference.

The two discussed the crisis, but so far, no mediated solution has emerged.

Copyright (c) 2007. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036. www.rferl.org

Comment and add to the story without registration, but keep the comments meaningful please. Links are not accepted.

Comments

#1 Iran and British Sailors

If British sailors have truly violated the territorial waters of Iran, then Iran’s condition to acknowledge that fact by UK in return of the sailors, seems to be only fair, and even very soft demand. We don’t want to create a world where someone can do a wrong thing and get away with that.

#2 Iran's demand

And conversely, if Iran took the British in international waters, then their demand cannot be accepted by the international community or there is no law of the high seas to rely on. This seems to be the case according to the GPS evidence.

#3 I agree with you Bhagwan.

I agree with you Bhagwan. Iran and UK should try to find the truth in what has happened. Finding the truth and apologizing for the wrong doing is good and should not be viewed as a sign of weakness.