Ukraine: EU Membership Ambition Revived As Summit Nears

Kyiv has reignited the controversy over its potential membership aspirations of the bloc ahead of the EU-Ukraine summit on October 27.

Ukraine's ambassador to the EU, Roman Shpek, says that as a "European country," Ukraine has a right to join the bloc - a sentiment that Brussels gave cautious support to today. But the highlight of the summit for Ukraine will likely be shorter-term gains - easing visa restrictions and cross-border movement with its EU neighbors.

European Country/European Future

Ukraine chose the eve of a summit meeting with the European Union to revive its controversial bid to win recognition to its eventual right to EU membership.
 
The bid is controversial for the EU, in that talk of any further expansion is becoming increasingly unpopular.

But Ukraine's membership aim is not without support. European Commission spokesman Johannes Laitenberg said today that Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso sees Ukraine as a "European country."
 
"President Barroso has indeed said that Ukraine is a European country that should have a European future," Laitenberg said. "As far as the agenda for EU-Ukraine relations is concerned, we have a clear and proactive agenda."
 
Ukrainian EU ambassador Shpek says there is nothing ambiguous about Kyiv's ambition. Speaking to journalists in Brussels on October 25, he quoted the EU's own Maastricht Treaty, which says that any European country may apply to join the bloc.
 
"We don't ask about the date of negotiations, or that of membership," Shpek said. "We ask: 'Please publicly recognize that Ukraine, like each European state, has a right to apply [for EU membership] according to Article 49.' Nothing more, for the time being."
 
EU treaties offer no definition of the term "European country." But Barroso and other EU officials have repeatedly described Russia as a European country, so it is only logical to extend the same description to Ukraine.
 
For now, however, the EU maintains relations between the two sides are adequately accommodated by the EU's Neighborhood Policy (ENP).
 
On The Continent
 
Ukraine, however, rejects this limitation. Shpek said Kyiv "accepts, but does not welcome" the ENP, as it does not consider itself a "neighbor."
 
He said Ukraine does not feel comfortable grouped together with countries like Morocco, Libya, or Israel. Instead, the country considers itself to be on a par with Serbia, which is guaranteed membership.
 
Shpek said that for Ukraine, Europe's borders lie in the Urals.
 
Accordingly, Ukraine would like to upgrade its existing partnership treaty with the EU once it expires in 2007. Kyiv would like the new treaty to affirm that Ukraine will one day be a member of the EU.
 
Should that not prove possible, Shpek said Ukraine may follow Poland.
 
Warsaw, which was denied candidate status in the early 1990s, nevertheless unilaterally implemented its cooperation agreement with the EU as if it were a candidate member.
 
Barroso has indicated that no new language will be added to the new treaty to reflect Ukraine's EU membership goals.
 
At the Helsinki summit, Kyiv will have to content itself with shorter-term concessions from the EU.
 
Shpek said Ukrainian Foreign Minister Borys Tarasyuk and EU External Relations Commissioner Benita Ferrero-Waldner will sign a long-awaited EU-Ukraine visa facilitation agreement.
 
"The Ukrainian minister of foreign affairs on Friday will sign together with Commissioner Ferrero-Waldner a visa-facilitation agreement and a readmission agreement," Shpek said. "And Ukraine welcomes the European Union's initiative that also European Union member states will clear a memorandum about small cross-border traffic."
 
Visa-For-Treaty
 
The visa-facilitation agreement will make it easier and cheaper for Ukrainian citizens to acquire EU visas. It return, Kyiv has consented to sign a readmission treaty with the EU, committing it to repatriating from the bloc any illegal immigrants who enter via Ukrainian territory.
 
The European Commission earlier this month proposed measures to facilitate small cross-border traffic on the EU's external borders, but this initiative still awaits member-state approval and requires the adoption of additional legislation.
 
Shpek also said the EU will offer assistance to help build up Ukraine's border-guard and customs services.
 
He said Ukraine will adopt the legislation necessary for the country's joining of the World Trade Organization (WTO) in December or early next year. Joining the WTO is a precondition for free trade with the EU.
 
Shpek also rejected suggestions that Russia may block Ukraine's accession to the WTO, saying both countries have undertaken not to present obstacles to each other.
 
Shpek said Ukrainian Prime Minister Viktor Yanukovych will not lift border controls against the Moldovan breakaway region of Transdniester. Ferrero-Waldner says she has received similar assurances from Kyiv. The EU is currently monitoring Trandniestrian borders to force its external trade to respect Moldovan laws.
 
Shpek added, however, that Ukraine doesn't "rule out new ideas and instruments" for the Transdniestrian border.
 
Alternative Pipelines
 
Shpek also said Ukraine is an ardent supporter of the EU's quest for alternative energy sources to reduce its dependence on Russia.
 
He said Kyiv is fully behind the so-called Nabucco pipeline project, which would turn Turkey into an important transit hub for the EU.

"For us, Nabucco, it's a very important project because it will deliver gas not only from Iraq, Iran, Pakistan, but also from Turkmenistan and Azerbaijan can reach the EU."
 
Shpek said Ukraine is also "ready to discuss" an initiative to build a gas pipeline across the Black Sea from Georgia to Ukraine.
 
He acknowledged the Black Sea route as being "shorter" than Nabucco, but added the project's approval depends on EU member states -- not all of which appear to be in favor.

Copyright (c) 2006. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036. www.rferl.org