An uproar has begun in a high school in Wisconsin over The Pledge of Allegiance being broadcast in Spanish over the Intercom. Once a year at Edgerton High School Spanish classes have recited the pledge. This year a parent got hot under the collar.
On March 11 the daily announcements at Edgerton High School had the Spanish class reciting the Pledge of Allegiance as it has for many years. It only happens one day per school year but this year is causing a fuss.
Parents are demanding that the Spanish teacher, the principal and the superintendent be fired over reciting the Pledge in a language other than English. On April 28 the issue will be front and center at the school board meeting.
The group against the once a year Spanish version have gone so far as to physically threatened Dr. Norman Fjelstad for what they believe.
“There were a couple of people who made threats,” he said. “I said, ‘It’s a felony to threaten me,’ and they apologized. Once they got set back on their heels, we had a good discussion. It’s the people who leave the messages on my phone—it’s like shooting you in the back. I don’t even know who they are.”
The uproar stems from some parents believing that by reciting the Pledge of Allegiance in any other language than English it is disrespectful to the troops.
Scott Angus of the Janesville Gazette the had run an article about the parents anger. After realizing that the issue at stake is mostly racist he pulled the debate.
“It started out fairly high brow,” Angus said, “but then it got to be a racist thing.”
Students and parents are saying that the issue is it’s not American to recite the Pledge in any other tongue than English yet when other languages from exchange students were on the announcements these parents didn’t push the bar, only when Spanish was spoken.
As one who posted their opinion in the Gazette said:
“I go to Edgerton High School and I don’t appreciate Mexicans saying the Pledge in Spanish. . . . If you think Mexicans can waltz right in this school and have an influence on these American students, then you’re wrong. This is America, home of the free and not the illegal.”
Those opposed to the Spanish version don’t care that 110,000 Spanish speaking members of the United States military serving the country in Iraq or Afghanistan would argue with them. That also don’t remember that during George W. Bush’s inaugural in 2001 the National Anthem was sung in Spanish.
“I’ve heard their frustration,” says Superintendent Fjelstad. “I understand what they’re saying. They feel it dishonors our troops serving in Iraq and Afghanistan. My response is this: I know there are 400 Hispanic speaking soldiers that won’t disagree with them. They can’t disagree because they gave their lives in Iraq and Afghanistan. However, there are 110,000 Spanish-speaking Hispanics serving in the military that I believe would agree with me that speaking Spanish does not dishonor the military.”
What do you think? Is this a patriotic argument or a bunch of parents trying to push racist views into school rulings?
Source: Moments In Time
Yes,it's disrepectful to not just the troops,but to
every american citizen!This is the United States and the pledge of alligiance should be in English.
There are thousands of Chinese and Japanese and Slavic and other languages that are spoken by people in this country but I've never heard the Pledge said in those languages. What all of the sudden do our children have to say the Pledge in Spanish. It's clear...the illegal immigrants speak mostly only Spanish and their supporters have an agenda of taking over the part of the U.S. that they claim is Mexican land. American is a melting pot with English as it's primary language. If millions of legal immigrants adjusted and learned English, then make it that way for anyone who enters our borders. Stop brainwashing our children into thinking Socialism is the way of our country.
For those of you who claim Americans who are against illegal immigrations are racists, you have no idea what it is to be a true American and support the country that our forefathers invisioned. It wasn't what we have now.
One thing you can count on, the "hispanic" members of the US armed forces took their oaths in english, not spanish. If they say the pledge, you can count of it being said in english, just as all other business in the military is.
1. The Constitution of the United States is written in English.
2. Pledging allegiance to a flag, particularly a flag you are not born under, lol, is a serious matter, if you are to take the PLEDGE seriously.
3. Understanding what the Constitution, its related documents, and the Pledge in particular, in English, is essential to the understanding of the WORDS, their CONTEXT, and the MINDSET of our Founding Fathers.
Learning the Pledge in spanish for class is one thing. To recite at a serious moment when UNITY IS THE THEME, one universal language should be used. Since english is the language of our constitution, and consequently the Pledge was written in english, so should it be recited.
Surely, the teacher/admins/etc knew this would incite an incident........
I personally feel that it is inappropriate for the Pledge of Allegiance to be recited in ANY language other than English, and the same is true for our National Anthem being sung in ANY language other than English. Yes, I feel that it is an insult to both our troops and our Nation to have the Pledge of Allegiance recited in ANY language other than English. I would also be having fits if my child attended this school and had to listen to this over a loudspeaker.
Mr. Fjelstad, these parents are speaking for themselves and how they personally feel about our Pledge being recited in another language. What gives you the right to speak for '110,000' plus soldiers, either living or deceased? Do you think they recite the Pledge of Allegiance in any language other than English while serving in our military? How do you think this makes immigrants who come here legally, are required to learn English and take pride in this effort, and then swear an oath of allegiance to our nation feel? You should be ashamed of yourself sir!
Before you accuse me of being a bigot, I am the granddaughter of European immigrants on one side of my family, and on the other side I am a member of the Daughters of the American Revolution. Some of my ancestors were Tejanos who fought in the Texas War of Independence, and I for one feel that you are belittling what they fought and died for.
SHAME ON YOU!
Oh,how shocking!! I'm just an American citizen who inherited this nation from my ancestors who sweated and fought wars and built it up for me, and well, I can't do anything about foreign nationals illegally here. I'm too dense, cowardly, or stupid. What do you expect of me. Oh, well, I guess it's a good thing to learn Spanish. I'll do whatever I havae to do, just leave me alone. SOUND ABOUT RIGHT??
The Pledge is a national symbol and was written in English, to be recited in English. Spanish is NOT a race. Only the socialist and communist traitors, in this country, use the race card for everything. Since the Superintendant thinks the same thing, he should be fired. We have enough socialist traitors running U.S. education, and our education levels and quality of life have reduced drastically because of it.
WHAT PEOPLE HAVE FORGOTTEN IS THAT A PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE IS A SACRED PLEDGE TO ONE'S COUNTRY. IT IS A VOW THAT WE OWE OUR LOVE AND OUR LIFE TO ONE'S NATION. IT IS NOT A SPELLING BEE, NOR IS IT A TEACHING TOOL. IT IS SACRED AND SHOULD BE RESPECTED AND SAID ONLY IN THE LANGUAGE OF THAT COUNTRY. IF THEY WANT TO TEACH A LANGUAGE, FINE BUT DON'T MESS WITH OUR PLEDGE!
This is EXACLTY why English needs to become the OFFICIAL language of the US! The irony -- the PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE US AND THE FLAG and for what it stands for is spoken in Spanish?!? It's repulsive! The liberal loons are going to ruin this country! People, wake up unless you want Spanish to be the official language. The Hispanics have a mission -- "The Reconquista" -- to reconquer what they believe is THEIRS -- the US! They've said they'll do it without firing a single shot (meaning they'll do it by reproducing and apparently it's working -- look around.) Get mad, get active or don't complain!
“There were a couple of people who made threats,” he said. “I said, ‘It’s a felony to threaten me,’ and they apologized. Once they got set back on their heels, we had a good discussion. It’s the people who leave the messages on my phone—it’s like shooting you in the back. I don’t even know who they are.”
I love Fjelstad condescending approach to United States Citizens(Once they got set back on their heels)while attempting to make his points in support of his Elitist Agenda. Everyone enjoys a lecture by such an Elitist and superior individual.
The Spanish speakers that were in my company, including my 1st Sgt, were from Purto Rico, held United States Citizenship and spoke ENGLISH. I can not recall a pledge or any functions in spanish. Sorry that this does not support Fjelstad's Elitist Agenda.
What is racist about this? Whenever those who pander to illegal immigration can't think of a logical response to the illegal immigration problem, they just yell "racist" out of frustration. They have nothing else to offer in the debate. I say enough is enough. It isn't racist to demand that Americans speak our official language in a government school.
How do you know the 110,000 would agree with you? Maybe they would respond as Americans and not by race.
THIS IS AMERICA! America's history, books, newspapers and speech are in ENGLISH. Our founding fathers debated, took notes & finally penned the Constitution in ENGLISH. The Bill of Rights and ALL OUR LAWS are in ENGLISH. To Be A LEGAL Citizen, the test is IN ENGLISH! THAT IN ITSELF DICTATES ENGLISH IS THE LANGUAGE OF AMERICA! ENGLISH NOT SPANISH!
LEGAL immigrants of the past came to AMERICA to be AMERICANS! Now it's more politically correct to insert your race, country of origin or religion BEFORE being an American. Such labeling SHOULD NOT be ACCEPTABLE TO AMERICANS OR TO ANYONE TRULY WANTING TO BE AN American.
NO OTHER group of "LEGAL" immigrants came to America and demanded America's laws and government documents be rewritten in their homeland languages. No other group of "LEGAL" immigrants, DID WHAT "ILLEGAL/CRIMINAL IMMIGRANTS" DID WHEN THEY raised their HOMELAND FLAGS in such numbers during immigration protests DEMANDING AMERICA GIVE THEM CITIZENSHIP AFTER BREAKING AMERICA'S LAWS & OUTRAGING THE AMERICAN PEOPLE. No other group of legal immigrants came to America and tried using her Constitution to change America's language, her laws and way of life to mimic their homeland. THAT HAS ALL CHANGED.
One of the most obscene and disturbing aspects of the present attack on the American way of life is MOST of these immigrants have ignored and broken America's immigration laws. In America, IF YOU BREAK THE LAW, YOU ARE A CRIMINAL. YOU ARE NOT ILLEGAL, NOT UNDOCUMENTED AND SURELY YOU SHOULD NOT BE ENTITLED TO USE AMERICA'S OTHER LAWS FOR YOUR BENEFIT.
Our public officials have adopted a “pick and choose the laws they want to be enforced” and “ignore the laws they don't like” against CRIMINAL IMMIGRANTS. Why isn't optional law enforcement available to "legal immigrants" or "American born citizens"? Where is the equality? Why do criminal immigrants get hords of free services when U.S. citizens GET NOTHING?
AMERICA WELCOMES LEGAL IMMIGRANTS WHO RESPECT HER LAWS AND CULTURES. IT'S A PRIVILEGE FOR ALL OF US TO LIVE IN AMERICA BUT IT COMES WITH RESPONSIBILITIES. It's become very clear a pattern to change America has developed. Americans must react to attacks on our culture viciously, BUT WE DON'T. Perhaps we should learn from the millions of Muslims worldwide who react with outrage at the slightest criticism of their religion. A united voice gets results & WE NEED IT NOW!
Claims that Americans Are Racist & Xenophobic ARE LIES & FALSE! Criminal Immigrants are XENOPHOBIC! It drives them INSANE to see how prosperous, happy & content Americans are with their lifestyle. It tears their hearts out seeing how legal immigrants assilmilated into American society.
Criminal Immigrants "ARE THE ULTIMATE XENOPHOBIC MASS OF PEOPLE EVER". They Have Such an intense fear & dislike of America's people, customs, culture & lifestyle. They drag their language, their tattered flag & memories of a government so corrupt it lets its people live in squallar. The RACISTS are the invaders of America & ALL the Rights Groups supporting them!
America is OUR sovereign nation with laws! The words “America, love it or leave it” should be resonating at the top of our lungs all across America. That was the vision of the future for America our founding fathers had and it should be ours too. America's soldiers did NOT DIE FOR OPEN BORDERS! If we don't react NOW, our history, our country and our way of life will definitely disappear. Write Your Lawmakers. Tell Them NO Citizenship for people who broke our laws & To Enforce existing laws, DO IT NOW!
Pledge of Allegiance
There is nothing racist about our pledge in English! This is American not Mexico, Germany, France or any other country. We are Americans!!!!!!